According to Josh Rasmussen, a Backroads Trip Leader and Guide in Salt Lake City, Utah, selecting the appropriate hiking boots is crucial as they can greatly impact the success of a trek. The requirements for hiking boots will vary depending on the individual, the terrain, and the weight of the backpack. Rasmussen suggests that if the trail is simple and the pack is light, lighter hiking shoes or even trail running shoes could be suitable. However, as the terrain becomes more challenging, it is important to choose hiking boots that provide increased ankle support.
In order to find the best hiking boots on the market, it is crucial to prioritize comfort, durability, and support. Additionally, these boots should offer protection against the elements and keep you firmly grounded with good traction. To ensure we were considering all these important factors, we sought advice from experts and conducted thorough research on numerous hiking boots. Subsequently, our team of testers hit the trails to assess each boot’s cushioning, comfort, fit, traction, stability, support, water resistance, blister protection, and overall value.
HOKA Kaha 2 GTX
After testing these boots in 2019 and hiking and backpacking over 800 miles globally, I still firmly believe that the men’s and women’s HOKA Kaha 2 GTX are the top lightweight hiking boots available for those who are willing to spend a bit more. Following the extensive use I subjected them to on various trails and terrains, I concur with the majority of outdoor media sources we consulted that the Hoka Kaha 2 boots are the ultimate upgrade in lightweight hiking footwear, and we highly endorse them.
The Hoka Kaha 2 is considered the best-selling lightweight leather hiking boot at REI stores across the nation and is widely recognized as one of the most sought-after options in the category of lightweight boots. Both professionals and regular reviewers share the same viewpoint as me in confirming that these boots are immediately comfortable, offer stability, and possess outstanding waterproofing and traction abilities.
These are the boots I rely on for backpacking or day hikes that exceed 5 or 6 miles in length. As a hiker, I prefer comfortable and well-cushioned boots, and HOKA has consistently been one of my preferred brands for hiking footwear.
Merrell Moab 3 Mid
Merrell has been manufacturing a model of the Merrell Moab 3 Mid for nearly twenty years, and it is widely regarded as one of the best hiking boots ever created, particularly for those on a limited budget. According to Outdoor Gear Lab, this shoe is reasonably priced and suitable for light to moderate hikes overall. Following our own assessments, we are confident in recommending these boots for both short and long hikes in diverse, arid terrains, believing they deliver equally impressive performance for hikers at any skill level.
One of the major advantages of choosing Merrells over other hiking boots is the wide range of materials and sizes they offer, which surpasses any other boots we have considered.
Out of the box, the Merrell Moab 3 boots felt solid and were much lighter than they looked. They have a mid-collar and all webbing eyelets except for the top eyelet, which is a hook. I liked this feature because I could cinch the laces tighter around my ankle. However, some reviewers have noted having an issue with the lacing system, saying, “I could not get the boot tight enough, so it kept slipping on my foot.”
Lowa Renegade GTX Mid
Lowa’s Renegade GTX is a durable boot that provides support for backpacking in challenging terrain. It effectively kept us protected from the elements, ensuring our comfort throughout our exploration of less frequented paths. The slim, water-resistant leather upper provided sufficient insulation while also allowing good breathability. Although they come with a high price tag, these boots are engineered to tackle any situation, making them a versatile option for off-road adventures, eliminating the need for multiple pairs.
While in complete submersion, our feet remained perfectly dry thanks to the gusseted tongue and GORE-TEX lining. Upon returning to the trail, we were pleased with the boot’s perforated footbed which effectively released heat and sweat, making it an ideal option for lengthy hikes.
The Renegade GTX has solid outsoles which can feel heavy and the midsole is stiffer compared to others on the list. However, these features make the boots grippy and supportive enough to handle rocks, snow, and dirt. We also appreciate the speed hook lacing that allows for a quick, customized fit. Although one tester mentioned that the boots are slightly narrow, it is fortunate that they are available in three widths.
La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX
Our award winners for Best Hiking Boots for Narrow Feet are the La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX. These boots were highly favored by our testers due to their sturdiness and breathability, making them the ideal choice for individuals with narrow feet. Additionally, they provide a cushiony feel, are easy to lace, and offer substantial arch support. Moreover, these boots have an appealing aesthetic compared to the other options we evaluated.
In 2017, when they were initially launched, Outside Magazine awarded them Gear of the Year. Since then, no changes have been made to the model. These shoes still receive excellent reviews from hikers with narrow feet.
Due to their narrow footbed, the La Sportiva stands out as the top choice for hikers with narrow feet due to their excellent fit.
The La Sportiva has a special feature called the “impact brake system,” which is a piece of hard rubber on the sole located at the back of the heel. This feature improves traction and decreases pressure on the heel during strikes. Gear Junkie includes, “They are sturdy hiking shoes suitable for various conditions, thanks to their versatile outsole and innovative Gore-Tex technology that effectively repels water…” and I fully concur with this statement.
Columbia Men’s Bugaboot III
Our top choice for a hiking boot that provides sufficient protection to keep your feet warm in cold temperatures is the Bugaboot III by Columbia. It is specifically designed to deliver versatile winter performance on various terrains, and it features thermal insulation, seam-sealed lining, and complete waterproofing. Through our testing, we discovered that the boot’s plush and padded collar, gusseted tongue, and tall profile effectively prevented snow and water from entering.
A key feature to consider when shopping for shoes for walking on ice is the Buggaboot. It has a removable, cushioned insole that absorbs shock and a multi-directional, anti-slip sole for stability. The protective rubber extends from the reinforced toe to the back, providing excellent traction. Additionally, we found it commendable that these boots didn’t leave marks on the floors after coming in from the cold.
In addition, these boots are lighter in weight compared to the majority of other pairs on our list. Notably, they are equipped with a lace-up closure that remains securely tied. However, it may be difficult to make adjustments while wearing gloves or mittens due to the absence of a speed lacing system. We suggest opting for a larger size in these boots, particularly if you intend to wear thick socks, as we discovered that they tend to run small and narrow.
